Fixed Probate Fees, call:

0800 612 6105


Alternatively local rate:

020 8150 2010

Contentious Probate

Looking at case law is the easiest way to assess how courts will deal with matters of contention with Wills. The recent case of Shah v Joshi considered some of the most common causes for claims. Mr Shah questioned the document which was claimed to be his mother’s last Will and Testament. The Will left the majority of the estate to his sister which contradicted an earlier Will which left most of her estate to him. The Will was dated just four weeks before the deceased’s death. It was written in English though she spoke only Gujarati and contained no attestation clause stating that it had been read or translated to the deceased who was also illiterate. The other fundamental claim against the validity of the document related to the signature of the deceased. Not only was the writing itself inconsistent with the deceased’s style of writing but also read (in Gujarati) Nirmalaben Kantibhai Shah. Mr Shah claimed his mother was known by the name Nirmalaben Kantilal Shah and, as she was not able to read or write, would not have known how to write her name any other way. Mr Shah claimed that the signature was a forgery and, even if it wasn’t, that his mother was too ill to understand and approve the contents of the Will. He also claimed, under the Inheritance Act, that it did not make reasonable financial provision for him and his family. The property which he shared with his mother (and owned a 1/3 share) before her death had been left to his sister in the new Will leaving them homeless. The trial involved a hand writing specialist, an expert on Gujarati custom and practice and medical evidence in relation to capacity. The solicitor who made the Will was called to give evidence along with the witnesses. The judge found that the signature had indeed been forged and could not have understood the contents given her mental condition at the time.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

------------------------

Call us today on:

0800 612 6105

Or on local rate:

020 8150 2010

------------------------

Alternatively email:

admin@iwc-ltd.co.uk